Off to the holy land!

This coming Thursday (24th Decemeber 2009) I am flying to the holy land for my very first time, Thank G-d. It is a special privilege and honour that I have been given, which I am very grateful for. I will be there until the 22nd of January.

If there anyone out there in Israel who reads my blog and would just like to say hi, please feel free to contact me ralevinsohn @ gmail. com perhaps we can meet up, would be great to meet some readers face to face.

Anyways, all the best to you all, chag samayach and hope to meet some (anyone?) of you in person.

 

 

 

 

The Dignity of Difference: The ways in which religions can be a source of peace rather than conflict

Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks is a true gadol and outstanding spokesman for our people. Please take the time to listen and absorb his thought provoking  and deeply insightful commentary how we as mankind can live in peace and harmony. Enjoy (Note the introductions lasts about 10min) Please distribute this lecture widely, it is truly remarkable.

(Hat tip to R'Dovid Sears for the link)

Rabbi Scherman on the demise of the English language

The Matzav newspaper recently published an interview with Artscroll co-founder Rabbi Nosson Scherman. The whole article was interesting, however the following paragraphs stuck out in my mind. On the one hand humorous, on the other hand a truly sad depiction of the quality of general education in certain sectors of our community.

Y.H.: How did you get such a strong background in English language skills?

N.S.: Yeshivos in general in those days had stronger general-studies departments than they have today. A very important influence was my friendship with Rabbi Nisson Wolpin and Rabbi Mendel Weinbach. They were two of my classmates, and we used to correspond. Rabbi Wolpin was from Seattle and Rabbi Weinbach was from Pittsburgh. During the summers we used to write letters. Does anyone correspond today? We wrote to each other-that helped. We tried to outdo each other; we were big-shot teenagers. The only way to learn how to write is to write. You know that. That is your craft. But it was those correspondences that helped a lot.

Y.H.: I have noticed that the word “ArtScroll” has taken on a new connotation in some circles. It has replaced the expression “highfalutin.” I have heard people say, “I can’t read that! It is written in ArtScroll English”-meaning with too high a vocabulary. Do you have any comment about that?

N.S.: We try as much as possible to avoid complex terminology. Simplify, simplify, simplify. I do try to avoid hefty words. When I edit others, I try to simplify what they are saying. If people feel that our English is not intelligible, it reflects the fact that they just don’t know English. It’s the American educational system.

Some great pictures

Rav Hertzog and Rav Uziel (Full Size )

 

Rav Shimon Shkop (Full Size , Full Size 2

Hat tip to Circus Tent

Surprising Theological Agreements: There Is Only One

There is a fascinating article "How not to make halachic rulings "  by Dr Daniel Sperber that is worth while reading. However, there is one particular segment that really came as a surprise to me. In the context of the sheitls made from India he goes into a whole debate whether in fact Hinduism (at least in some versions) is really monotheistic and compatabile/acceptable(?) to Judaism. Read the entire article for some important cavets, but the following extracts should serve as food for though – very interesting indeed:

On the fifth and sixth of February this year, I participated in the first "Hindu-Jewish Leadership Summit" at Delhi, India. This summit was attended by a delegation of the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and some prominent European rabbis, and religious leaders of the Hindu Dharma. I was asked to participate, perhaps because I had served briefly as a rabbi in India many years ago, and was therefore thought to have some understanding of Indian culture and religion.

Many leading Achariahs and Swamis from all over India were present, and a very lively and probing dialogue took place. In our discussions we asked them whether Hinduism is a polytheistic and idolatrous religion, and they all unanimously and most vigorously denied such an assertion, explaining the apparent outward manifestations of idolatry in a completely different fashion.

At the end of the conference, a "Declaration of Mutual Understanding and Cooperation" was co-signed by all participants. Perhaps the most significant clause in the whole document in this context is the opening one:

The participants affirmed that:

1) Their respective traditions teach Faith in One Supreme Being
who is the Ultimate Reality, who has created this world in its
blessed divinity and who has communicated Divine ways of action
for humanity for different peoples in different times and places.

[1]  They base this assertion on passages from the most ancient and canonical of their sacred writings, whose formulations surely attest to such belief. The following are some examples that they offer:

Rgveda Sambita

There is one reality; the wise speak of it in various ways. Rg. Veda.I.164.46c

Chandogya Upanisad (Sama Veda)

Only one non-dual limitless reality. ChU 6.2.1

Brhadaranyaka Upanisad (Shuklayajur Veda)

There is no second thing here at all. BrU 4.4.19

Taittiriya Upanisad (Krsnayajur Veda)

The one that is in this person is the one that is in the universe; he is one. TaiU 2.8.5

Katha Upanisad: (Krsnayajur Veda)

He has no sound, no texture, no form, is changeless, free from taste, time and smell, has no beginning or end, is beyond the intellect and absolutely constant. KaU 1.3.15

A series of verses (2.2.9-12) in this Upanisad uses illustrations to show that the one being is both immanent and transcendent.

Just as fire, which is one, having entered the world, assumed a form corresponding to each of its manifestations, so too the being self within all beings, who is one, assumed a form corresponding to each, yet is apart (transcendent). KaU 2.2.9

Just as air, which is one, having entered the world, assumed a form corresponding to each of its manifestations, so too the being within all beings, who is one, assumed a form corresponding to each, yet is apart (transcendent). KaU 2.2.10

Just as the sun, which is the eye of the world, is not touched by the defects of external things that are seen, so too the being within all beings, who is one and transcendent, is not touched by the grief of the world. KaU 2.2.11

One being within all beings, who is the master, who makes a single form manifold – those wise ones who recognize clearly that one who abides in themselves, have lasting happiness, not anyone else. KaU 2.2.12

Svetasvatara Upanisad (Krsnayajur Veda)

The one effulgent being, hidden in all beings, all-pervasive, the being/self within all beings, who presides over actions and their results, who dwells in all beings, the witness, consciousness, who is absolute and free from attributes, SvU 6.11

Kena Upanisad (Sama Veda)

That which is not revealed by speech, and by which speech is revealed; know only that as Brahaman, not what people worship as an object. KaU 1.5

That which is cannot be thought of by the mind, and because of which, they say, the mind thinks: know only that as Brahman, not what people worship as an object. KaU 1.6

That which one does not see with the eyes, and because of which the eyes see; know only that as Brahman, not what people worship as an object. KaU 1.7

Mundaka Upanisad (Atharva Veda)

The one who cannot be seen or grasped, who has no lineage or class, no ear or eye (no limitation in knowledge) or hand or foot (no limitation in power), is free from time, all-pervasive, extremely subtle, changeless and the source of all beings, the wise ones recognize clearly. MuU 1.6

What were we talking about again?

Having been a member of the Orthodox Jewish blogosphere for quite a few years now, I was recently reflecting on some major "controversies" that have caught our interest at one time or another. Off the top of my head here are some of the major items that come to mind. Some of these issues have long been forgotten, others pop up once in a while and others in some form or another are still thriving.

  • Lubavitch Messianism and theological positions regarding manifestations of Divinity
  • The Slifkin Saga: creation and contemporary science, the existence/non existence of mysterious creatures, the fallibility/infallibility of scientific statements in rabbinic literature
  • Making of a Gadol: censorship, the white washing of history and the fallibility of rabbinic authorities
  • Kashrut Scandals: Sheitals from Indian Hair, Brooklyn Water, Treif meat in Monsey
  • The Limits of Orthodox Jewish dogma: Marc Shapiro book on the Rambam's Thirteen Principles of Faith
  • The removal of the settlements in Gush Katif
  • Cases of sexual abuse and their cover ups
  • Cases of rabbinic misconduct
  • Cases of prominent Jewish individuals breaking the law )
  • Chumrah society: the shifting to the right, once permissible practices and opinions that are now no longer acceptable
  • “Daas Torah”

Have I missed anything? Let me know in the comments section.

A rare picture of the Gerrer Rebbe

 

 

Full Sized Picture Here:  

Source: Pg 82, Hasidism (Popular Judaica library), Aryeh Rubinstein, Keter Books 1975

Amazing pictures of the Satmar Rebbe

See here for the entire photo gallery

Beautiful Music:

To attain victory over unconstraint and destructive atheism, we must educate Torah scholars who are healthy physically and healthy in all their non-physical aspects.

They must be educated intelligently with the ability to recognize the sweet feelings that come from dealing with the most elevated aspect of beauty-whether in song and poetry, the glory of nature, or whether it is the beauty that stands out in the works of mankind.

"A beautiful dwelling place, a beautiful wife and beautiful clothes broaden a person's mind" (Talmud).


Orot Ha'Emunah, p. 17
(http://ravkook.net/poetry.html)

 

Gheorghe Zamfir – The Lonely Shepherd –  In my opinion one of the most beautiful pieces of music ever created. B"H, Enjoy!

 

  Also a great new single, from Matisyahu – One Day, literally brings tears to your eyes

 

Sikh Delegation meets Rabbi Froman

As mentioned in a previous post , Rabbi Froman is a peacemaker, trying to build bridges between distant, often warring communities. With so much bad press surrounding Orthodox jews of late, I thought it would be beneficial to bring some attention to some good news items (This happened a couple of years ago, but still good news nonetheless)

Here are some great pictures of him meeting a delegation of Sikhs.

 

 

See here for some more great pictures and the full article: